Help

Controverse Guide

A Crag Guide gives an extensive view of all sub areas and climbs at a point in the index. It shows a snapshot of the index heirachy, up to 300 climbs (or areas) on a single web page. It shows selected comments climbers have made on a recently submitted ascent.

At a minor crag level this should be suitable for printing and taking with you on a climbing trip as an adjunct to your guidebook.

This guide was generated anonymously. Login to show your logged ascents against each route.

Warning

Rock climbing is extremely dangerous and can result in serious injury or death. Users acting on any information directly or indirectly available from this site do so at their own risk.

This guide is compiled from a community of users and is presented without verification that the information is accurate or complete and is subject to system errors. By using this guide you acknowledge that the material described in this document is extremely dangerous, and that the content may be misleading or wrong. In particular there may be misdescriptions of routes, incorrectly drawn topo lines, incorrect difficulty ratings or incorrect or missing protection ratings. This includes both errors from the content and system errors.

Nobody has checked this particlular guide so you cannot rely on it's accuracy like you would a store bought guide.

You should not depend on any information gleaned from this guide for your personal safety.

You must keep this warning with the guide. For more information refer to our:
Usage policy

Contributors

Thanks to the following people who have contributed to this crag guide:

Benjamin Castonguay Amanda Green Cedric Bariteau Raymond Kam Horizen jessica hooper Paul

The size of a person's name reflects their Crag Karma, which is their level of contribution. You can help contribute to your local crag by adding descriptions, photos, topos and more.

Table of contents

1. Controverse 12 routes in Cliff

Summary:
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D

Seasonality

Sport climbing and Trad climbing

access issues

The climbing area is maintained by "Parc d'Escalade et de Randonnée de la Montagne D'Argent" (PERMA) -- primarily a climber's organisation. Daily access fee was $14 as of summer 2021, and yearly memberships ($70 as of 2021). Being affiliated with the Alpine Club of Canada, members of certain sections may climb for free upon presentation of their club membership but are still required to pay for on-site camping.

On weekends, there is generally someone there to collect the fees, during the week this is more often done on the honour system.

The site is open all year round with artificial ice falls created over the cliffs over the freezing winter months for Technical Ice Climbing.

A complete guidebook (including hand drawn reproductions, contributed by a local artist) is generally available at the hut on weekends. It has maps for access to the cliffs, and drawings of all the cliffs with routes marked on them. The current official guidebook is fully bilingual.

inherited from Montagne d'Argent
RouteGradeStyleSelected ascents
1 La bedaine de Gerard 5.11d Sport 25m, 9
2 Les tetons de Grand-papa

An alternate finish to Gerard, branching right after the 3rd bolt.

5.11b Mixed trad 25m, 7
3 Les tetines de Grand-maman 5.11a Sport 25m, 10
4 Serpent referendaire

Bolts shown in the MdA guide do not exist. Indicated start is, also, much harder than 5.7 -- it should naturally climb the flake and ramp right of the bulge with the bolt on it, cross over the top of this to the main crack, then up the indicated crack to anchors.

FA: Jean-Claude Neolet, 1995

5.7 PG Trad 25m
5 Escouade tactile

Warning Fixed Gear: Inadequate Bolting

The distance between the first and second bolt is greater than the distance between the ground and first bolt. There is a high likelihood of a ground fall if you fall near the second bolt. You will not walk away from such a fall.

The lower three bolts in the MdA guide book don't exist on the climb. Look for a high first bolt on a slabby bulge a few meters left of Controverse.

FA: Gaetan Castilloux, 1995

5.10b X Sport 25m, 6
6 controverse

A lovely close-bolted climb that is tough at its grade. From the main ledge, climb the left side of the slab, then angle left-wards, up the face to a ledge on the right, up onto another ledge to its left, then up to the anchors.

5.8 Sport 25m, 10
7 friction constitutionnelle

Climbs up the center line of bolts up the slab just off the main ledge -- starting with a small indented dish, and staying on or slight left of the 3rd bolt for full value. After the third bolt, go straight back, clipping the bolt slight right (and ignoring the stray bolt to the left -- it is on no climb). A nice couple of friction moves near the bolt, then an easy walk to the anchors in the head wall..

FA: Jean-Claude Neolet, 1995

5.8 Sport 15m, 4
8 nagasaki

A nice introduction to friction climbing, though sparsely bolted. Follow the right-most set of bolts from the main Controverse ledge.

The 2nd bolt as indicated in the MdA guidebook now exists.

FA: Jean-Claude Neolet, 1995

5.6 Sport 20m, 3
9 hiroshima

Start right of Nagasaki, and climb to the obvious crack in the first face, over top of this, angle up and rightwards along the base of the overlap, then eventually turn left and up to the anchors.

Everything after the first face is now bolted, and there is a 2-bolt anchor at the first ledge.

If you start on Nagasaki, then go right at the first ledge (past the anchors) the entire thing can now be climbed as a sport climb.

FA: Jean-Claude Neolet, 1995

5.5 Mixed trad 30m, 9
10 La cheminee du Pere Noel

This climb is above the main cliff, and is best approached by climbing Hiroshima.

FA: Jean-Claude Neolet, 1995

5.5 Trad 12m

1.1. Right of Controverse 2 routes in Sector

Summary:
All Sport climbing

description

Just right of the main Controverse area there is a small, very gentle, face with a couple bolted routes on it.

These appear to be intended as utter beginner/learning routes -- incredibly closely bolted and very easy climbing.

From Controverse ledge, climb over the large roof boulder and you'll see these to the right, or continue a bit farther down the main trail past controverse, and then look leftwards off the trail for a gently, low, slab area.

RouteGradeStyleSelected ascents
1 Péché Mignon

Starts at the left leg of the face and goes up that side over a series of easy block ledges. It is very close-bolted. Good intro to sport climbing lead.

Set: Laurent Cloutier, 2011

Maint: Team M$, 7 Jul 2021

5.3 Sport 23m, 9
2 Arrête Pas

Up the arrête on the right leg/side of the face. Closely spaced bolts. Great introduction to friction climbing basics.

Set: Laurent Cloutier, 2011

Maint: Team M$, 14 Jul 2021

5.4 Sport 20m, 8

2. Index by grade

Grade Stars Name Style Pop Area
5.3 Péché Mignon Sport 23m, 9 1.1. Right of Controverse
5.4 Arrête Pas Sport 20m, 8 1.1. Right of Controverse
5.5 La cheminee du Pere Noel Trad 12m 1. Controverse
hiroshima Mixed trad 30m, 9 1. Controverse
5.6 nagasaki Sport 20m, 3 1. Controverse
5.7 PG Serpent referendaire Trad 25m 1. Controverse
5.8 controverse Sport 25m, 10 1. Controverse
friction constitutionnelle Sport 15m, 4 1. Controverse
5.10b X Escouade tactile Sport 25m, 6 1. Controverse
5.11a Les tetines de Grand-maman Sport 25m, 10 1. Controverse
5.11b Les tetons de Grand-papa Mixed trad 25m, 7 1. Controverse
5.11d La bedaine de Gerard Sport 25m, 9 1. Controverse
Deutsch English Español Français Italiano 한국어 Português 中文